Starkweather Brewing Co logo

Starkweather Brewing Co.

Starkweather Brewing Co.

2439 Atwood Avenue, Madison, WI 53704
(608) 467-6949
First Visited: September 5, 2022

Located in the Schenk-Atwood-Starkweather-Yahara neighborhood, the aptly named Starkweather Brewing Company made its debut on February 10, 2022. This establishment took over the premises formerly occupied by Next Door Brewing Company.

Originally established in 2013, Next Door Brewing had set up shop in a building that had previously served as an appliance repair store. The initial partnership of Crystal and Aric Dieter, Phil Dieter, Keith Symonds, and Pepper Stebbins contributed to its success, with Crystal and Aric Dieter becoming the primary owners in 2014. Known for its excellent beer, delectable food, and cozy atmosphere, Next Door had garnered a loyal following.

Although Next Door closed its physical location in 2021, the brand continued to thrive through distribution. Potosi Brewery now contract brews their beer, which remains available in bottles and cans at local stores throughout Wisconsin.

Tom Gosse, Thomas McVary, Michael Chronister, and Brewmaster Peter Schroder, all residents of Madison’s east side and with a shared passion for brewing, came together as the owners and general managing partners of Starkweather Brewing. Even before securing the location, they had chosen the name Starkweather Brewing as a homage to the nearby creek. McVary and Schroder had met at Next Door and had previously discussed the idea of opening a brewery together, while Chronister and Gosse were regular patrons of Next Door and members of the mug club. The opportunity to own a brewery aligned perfectly with their aspirations.

While considering various options for their business, including an attempt to acquire One Barrel Brewing on Atwood Avenue, the partners ultimately found the ideal fit in the available Next Door location. They were captivated by its appeal and believed it met all their requirements. This venture marked the first foray into business ownership for all four partners, and they were enthusiastic about establishing their brewery as a neighborhood hotspot. They did not make any major renovations and was only closed for a short spell while they did some rebranding and light remodeling before their grand opening in Feb 22.

Starkweather Brewing primarily features beers crafted by Brewmaster Peter Schroder, a decorated professional and home brewer. Although they may occasionally offer other local brews, the majority of the tap list showcases Schroder’s creations. Additionally, one tap line is dedicated to gluten-free beer. Schroder’s experience spans several local breweries in the Madison area, and he served as the former president of the Sun Prairie Wort Hogs Home Brewing Club.

Schroder, originally from the Netherlands, attributes his passion for experimenting with flavors to growing up in a place with limited beer choices. Surprisingly, he initially lacked interest in brewing until his wife gifted him a home brewing kit over a decade ago, sparking his curiosity and igniting his brewing journey.

Well-versed in the local beer scene, Schroder has collaborated with various Madison-area brewers over the past decade, including Ale Asylum, House of Brews, MobCraft, Dead Bird, and Rockhound. He even brewed at Next Door in 2014 alongside Keith Symonds, the brewer at the time. Prior to launching Starkweather, Schroder managed the brewhouse at One Barrel Brewing for a period.

Starkweather Brewing’s inaugural year has been characterized by Schroder’s eclectic approach, resulting in over 66 unique beers, most of which are one-offs. A select few, such as the Lake Loop cream ale, HOP-MYHZ hazy IPA, and Sweet Heat gose with scorpion pepper and pineapple, are available more frequently.

Additionally, Starkweather Brewing has engaged in discussions with Olbrich Gardens regarding the incorporation of their spices, herbs, and fruits in their beers. The plan is to feature Olbrich products in three brews each year, further enhancing their distinct flavors.

Embodying the legacy of the Starkwater name, the brewery remains dedicated to utilizing locally-sourced ingredients and crafting beers that strike the perfect balance between rich flavors and wide accessibility.

Starkweather Brewing Company serves as a community-focused gathering place in the heart of Madison’s East Side and a welcoming destination for all to explore a dynamic, ever-changing menu of finely crafted beer.

Beers Tried

Summer Breeze

Blonde Ale

5.3% ABV

25 IBU

Rating: 3.67

Blonde Ale with peaches

Smooth Sailing

Wheat Beer – Other

4.9% ABV

21 IBU

Rating: 3.62

Blueberry wheat ale


Barleywine – American

9.2% ABV

48 IBU

Rating: 3.71

American style Barley wine, a brew guest brew master Peter Schroder wanted to demonstrate. Big malt forward ale with citrus and some nutty notes.


IPA – American

7.4% ABV

Rating: 3.62

An American IPA with Mango Habanero added.


Porter – American

5.6% ABV

27 IBU

Rating: 3.73

Robust Chocolate Porter.


IPA – New England / Hazy

6.8% ABV

20 IBU

Rating: 3.42

First hazy IPA from your favorite local brewery! This hazy IPA is brewed with Moutere hops, creating a versatile aroma including passionfruit and citrus.

Photo Gallery